|
The Coming Saudi Oil War
Reprinted from Early Warning Report, February 1995, with updates from the March 1999 EWR and August 2000 EWR
By Richard Maybury
Copyright © 1995-2003 by Henry Madison Research, Inc.
www.richardmaybury.com
1-800-509-5400, Fax 602-943-2363
For US investors,
Saudi Arabia is one of the most important countries in the world.
It's the largest oil exporter, containing somewhere between 25%
and 30% of the known world oil supply. When Saudi Arabia sneezes,
US investment markets catch pneumonia.
While we cannot be certain,
it looks like a big sneeze is just around the corner. The exact
timing is not predictable, but when it happens, investors who
are in the right oil investments [see Crude
Oil Strips] will profit enormously. Those who aren't will
be seriously hurt.
Here's the Story
Look at a world map from the
last century and you'll find the Arabian peninsula labeled Arabia,
not Saudi Arabia. This seems a small point, but it's the key
to understanding what's happening.
Saudi Arabia is
a giant desert: a third the size of the US, but with only 17
million people. (The US has 258 million.) When I flew over the
"Empty Quarter," I felt as if I were flying over the
surface of the moon. Most of the Arabian peninsula is so dry
and worthless that until this century, few tribes bothered to
draw the boundaries between their territories.
Until the early Middle Ages,
the peninsula was inhabited only by a few nomadic bands. Then
it was divided into numerous states often at war with each other.
One of these was the Saud family dynasty, founded in the 1400s.
In the 1500s, the Turks gained
control of the area along the Red Sea called the Hejaz, and in
the 1800s, the British took parts of Hasa and Oman along the
east coast and Aden in the southwest tip of the Arabian peninsula.
The wars among the tribes continued
until the 1930s when ibn-Saud, backed by the British, finally
conquered the other tribes. He established the state of Saudi
Arabia, roughly within its present boundaries. Yemen and the
other small states of the Arabian peninsula are the lands ruled
by tribes the Saudis did not subdue.
|
Please see the latest figures and numbers on a sample "Strips"
in the most current publication, visible on this site: Crude
Oil Options: STRIPS, March 2001.
No guarantees, but I think there is a 70% chance of something
enormous happening in the Persian Gulf by the end of the decade,
and 90% within five years. In EARLY
WARNING REPORT I will continue keeping you informed.
-- Richard Maybury
The risk of loss in futures and options can
be substantial, therefore only genuine risk funds should be used.
The risk of loss in buying options on futures can result in the
total loss of the premium paid plus transaction costs. Past profits
are not necessarily indicative of future profits. This estimate
was calculated by Investors Publishing Services, Inc. (IPS).
The opinions contained herein do not necessarily reflect the
views of any individual or other organization. Material was gathered
from sources believed to be reliable; however, no guarantee to
its accuracy is made.
|

Why is the Name Saudi Arabia So Important?
It causes the misleading assumption
that members of the Saudi family are the rightful owners of the
place and the rightful representatives of the people. It's as
if a Canadian family named Ferguson had conquered Canada and
had the gall to rename it Ferguson Canada, and everyone in the
world including the USG (US Government) now referred to all Canadians
as Fergusons. It is one of the most successful hoaxes in history.
The Saudis are dictators who
rule the other tribes with a heavy hand. If they didn't have
all that oil, other cultures would regard them as just one more
group of thugs in the same league as Qadaffi, Assad and Saddam
Hussein.
The key point for our investments
is that the Saudi royal family is roundly hated by their subjects.
The king and his tribe live in great opulence that provokes much
jealously. Everyone knows the Saudi tribe has no more rightful
claim to the oil money than any other tribe.
The Saudis have two armies
so that if one revolts they can pit the other one against it.
Their primary means of preventing
revolts has been to spread some of the wealth around in the theory
that if the population can be kept in a kind of welfare stupor
like domesticated cattle, few will have the initiative to revolt.
So far it's worked.
They allow no freedom of speech
or press. Every non-Saudi knows that if he gets caught saying
something unflattering about a member of the royal family, he
could vanish.
It's a big family. Ibn-Saud
had 150 wives, so today a legion of 6,000 Saudi princes occupy
the most important and high-paying jobs and keep the economy
in a chokehold of nepotism.
Political parties are not permitted.
Activists are arrested and tortured, including electric shock
and flogging. Judges are influenced by the royal family and they
can be overruled by the king.
No one in the Islamic world
ever forgets that the hated Saudi conquerors sit atop 260 billion
barrels of oil and they got there with the help of one of Islam's
oldest enemies, Britain. Worse, the Saudis are trying to stay
there with the help of Britain's ally, the US. This is a time
bomb that will go off. Count on it. The only question
is when.
|
Now that you know about some of the turmoil brewing in the
Persian Gulf, I suggest that when you invest in oil companies
you make sure they are well run firms with little debt, lots
of oil or gas in the ground, and little or no holdings in Chaostan.
I suggest Berry Petroleum (BRY, NYSE), Murphy Oil (MUR, NYSE)
and American Gas Index Fund (1-800-622-1386).
You will find a list of more than three dozen investments
expected to profit from the turmoil in Chaostan in the July 1997
EARLY WARNING REPORT.
|
Tensions Are Rising
Despite the carloads of money
earned by all that oil, the Saudis are now managing to spend
it faster than they can make it. Infrastructure is going without
repairs as contractors wait more than six months to be paid.
Some neighborhoods experience frequent water cutoffs. Hospital
beds are in short supply. New homes sit empty for lack of electrical
service.
As the Saudi welfare state
crumbles, the influence of Islamic rebels is increasing. Underground
faxes written against the royal family are widely read and discussed.
Popular music has become openly antiroyal. A line in one song
says, "Kings when they enter a country despoil it and make
the noblest of its people the lowest."
Middle class Arabs keep mental
lists of the rumored prices of each royal palace.
Jokes depict the king as a
witless tyrant. This is very important. The one weapon no government
can stand against is ridicule. Once bureaucrats, police and troops
are embarrassed to be a part of the institution, their morale
drops, they quit doing their jobs, and that's the end of it.
(If you really want to fight back against the Washington power
structure, compile a list of jokes about it and pass it around.)

How Hopeless is the Situation?
Try to imagine: the Saudis
have a fourth of all the oil in the world and a population of
only 17 million - the same as Texas - yet they are spending the
money so fast they're broke.
The royal family's connections
with Britain and the US discredit them even further since the
US-UN arms embargo of the earlier 1990s in the Balkans led to
the slaughter of thousands of Moslems. Said Saudi Arabia's Al-Yawm
newspaper: "The United Nations bears responsibility for
what is happening now in Bosnia."
The royal family's complete
dependence on the protection of the West was demonstrated in
the Iraq-Kuwait war. When the ground war began on January 16,
1991, the Saudi troops immediately abandoned their equipment
and fled to take cover behind US lines. A disgusted British officer
said, "They bugged out."
|
"If the world has seemed a messy place since the end
of the cold war, it has lately been getting sharply messier."
THE ECONOMIST, 1/14/95
|
A Nitroglycerine Combination
As if all those historical
and financial problems were not enough, Saudi Arabia also contains
Mecca and Medina. These are Islam's two holiest cities. This
means the shrines that are Islam's most sacred are under control
of a regime that is widely perceived as Islam's most corrupt.
A nitro and glycerine combination if there ever was one. Imagine
how Catholics would feel if the Vatican were conquered and controlled
by Al Capone.
A popular song is titled "Islam
vs. Christianity," and Moslems everywhere wonder which side
the Saudi royal family is really on.
In 1981, President Reagan pledged
US protection for the Saudi regime against all enemies, internal
as well as external. This means, apparently, that when the Saudi
rulers finally do come under attack by their own people, their
dictatorship will be protected by US troops. I wonder how many
US troops realize what they've signed on for. Do they remember
it was the Saudis who led the 1973 oil embargo against the US?

The End of the Saudi Royal Family
We can never be sure about
these things, but the great rebellion in Saudi Arabia may be
near, due to breakthroughs in electronics.
As with all dictatorships,
the primary means the Saudis use to control their people is to
control the information the people receive. For several years,
Saudi police have been searching out and destroying satellite
TV dishes which receive uncensored news broadcasts from space.
But the dishes are being downsized; some now are as small as
18" in diameter and can be hidden anywhere. Also, phone
line access to the Internet is fast becoming universal.
So, I believe the new electronics
combined with the financial crisis means the end of the Saudi
royal family. My guess is that Iran's secret agents will continue
working to foment revolution, and they'll do it in a way designed
to prevent US intervention. The rebels will claim to be fighting
for a more democratic Arabia. Once they've succeeded and are
in power, they will request assistance from Iran to "stabilize"
Arabia. This voluntary invitation to Iran by the new "democratic"
government will be an end run that will deprive the USG of justification
to intervene.

A Puppet of Iran
The new Arabian government
will be, in effect, a puppet of Iran, and Iran will get de facto
ownership of all that oil. If Iran can also take the small Persian
Gulf oil states in the process, they will end up controlling
half of all the oil in the world.
The USG has little understanding
of Saudi Arabia. As in Iran in the 1970s, US officials deal with
the English-speaking elite and get only their view of things.
When the big rebellion happens, today's politicians will probably
be as surprised as their predecessors when the Shah of Iran was
overthrown.
Saudi Arabia is the most thoroughly
crazy place I've ever visited. A whole list of descriptions comes
to mind. Weird, balmy, psychotic, Alice in Wonderland. The only
thing certain is that it cannot last. Saudi Arabia will
go back to being Arabia, and the bloody transition will
cause oil prices to soar. When? We cannot know, human behavior
is difficult to predict. We can say only that with the financial
problems, the decline of the welfare handouts and the new advances
in electronics, the stage is now set.
In all the Islamic world, the
only tribe that's despised more than the Saudis is the Kuwaitis,
who also got where they are with the help of the much hated British
and US. I still believe the forecast that makes the most sense
is this: Iraq and Iran will continue working secretly to get
the US armed forces hopelessly tangled up in the Balkans and
elsewhere. Then they will foment revolutions in Kuwait and Saudi
Arabia. Iraq will take Kuwait and Iran will take the rest of
the Persian Gulf plus Mecca and Medina.
Eventually - maybe immediately,
maybe later - Iraqis and Iranians will fight among themselves
for ownership of the whole prize, and all the Persian Gulf oil
fields will go up in flames as Kuwait's did in 1991.

What to Look For
Generally, when a government
gets into the kind of trouble the Saudis have gotten themselves
into, it will try to buy time by printing money. A leading indicator
to watch is the value of the Saudi currency, the riyal. It's
reported daily in the WALL STREET JOURNAL
and other major newspapers. If we see the value of the riyal
begin to decline dramatically, I will take this as a sign the
big revolt is near and I should get more deeply into oil investments
[see Crude Oil Strips].
The exact timing is impossible
to predict, so I keep a certain number of these investments in
my portfolio at all times.
Warn everyone you care about,
it looks like the Great Chaos is about to mushroom.
Richard Maybury, February 1995 EWR
Update - Saudi Oil War —March 1999 EWR
In the 2/95 EWR you received one of my most important articles, "The Coming Saudi Oil War." I explained some of the history few westerners understand, and said the US-backed Saudi dictatorship was in deep economic trouble and headed for a revolution, probably fomented by Iran.
Saudi Arabia is crucial to the world economy and our investments. The single biggest influence on oil prices, it contains 25% of the total world oil supply and, backed by Washington, dominates the Persian Gulf which contains an aggregate 65% of the oil.
On the opposite side of the Gulf is Iran, which is Persia. An ancient civilization with a population of 67 million, this is is the 400-pound gorilla of the Persian Gulf. Persia owned the Gulf for more than 2,000 years until London and Washington stole it and installed the Saudi royal family as their puppet overlords during the 20th century.
A big mystery has arisen in the Persian Gulf and the mainstream press says nothing about it.
The Saudi welfare state's finances have been deteriorating for years, and recent low oil prices have worsened the strain. The standard of living of all but the ruling elite has fallen sharply, and the poor in this once fabulously rich nation cannot even afford to buy meat.
Yet, the revolution has gone away. The flood of dissident petitions, faxes and videos denouncing royal corruption and the ties with Washington has largely dried up.4
Washington and London are delighted, of course. There have been no bombings since the 1996 Dhahran incident that killed 19 Americans.
But, the neighboring island of Bahrain, also suffering from low oil prices, grows more violent by the week, which is what we would expect.
In other words, economic conditions in the Persian Gulf are much worse than when I wrote "The Coming Saudi Oil War," yet in Saudi Arabia, the Iranian-backed rebels have grown quiet, as if they no longer want the Saudi regime overthrown. Strange.
I think Saudi King Fhad's brother Abdullah is the explanation. After the 1996 bombing, the effort to maneuver Abdullah into the throne accelerated. Fhad's health now is terrible, and by the end of 1998 Abdullah had become the de facto Saudi king.
Abdullah is known to be more friendly to Iran and other enemies of Washington.
Think about it. As Abdullah has risen, the rebels have grown more quiet despite worsening economic conditions.
My guess is that the revolution is gone because it has succeeded. Abdullah secretly capitulated and formed a clandestine alliance with Iran.
The Iranian regime does not need to take the Saudi oil fields by force, they already own them. The Saudi oil war is over, the US lost.
If I am right, what happens next?
First an observation. If the Saudi and Iranian dictators are secretly in bed together, then both sides of the Persian Gulf are now in the hands of Washington's enemies. Clinton keeps about two dozen US Navy ships in the Gulf. Ergo, two dozen US Navy ships are surrounded.
The only escape from the Gulf is through the Strait of Hormuz, which is 40 miles wide, an easy missile shot.
The shallow Persian Gulf is really an Iranian lake - a bottle with a single, narrow opening.
Fish in a barrel.
In Somalia we saw that Bill Clinton is a military genius in the tradition of George Armstrong Custer. Are we about to see it again, on a much larger scale?
Iran's goals are no secret. For two decades they have been to (1) raise oil prices as high as possible, (2) humiliate Washington and seriously damage the US economy and armed forces and, (3) take back the Persian Gulf.
If I were the Iranians what would I do? In January, when Y2K problems hit the highly computerized US Army, Navy and Air Force, I'd mine the Strait of Hormuz, launch a cloud of cruise missiles at the US ships bottled up in the Gulf, and announce that Persia has taken back the Persian Gulf including the oil.
And then there's Yassir Arafat and the cigar. Will Arafat help create terrorist attacks to augment Iran's strike?
Of course, my analysis could be wrong. We have no solid evidence of a secret alliance between the Saudi and Iranian regimes. But when it comes to the oil investments I have written so much about over the past year, and which are so dependent on events in the Mideast, it is always important to keep in mind that covert warfare was invented nine centuries ago in Iran. As my Iranian friend says, "In the Mideast, whatever appears to be happening is not what is happening, and whoever appears to be responsible is not who is responsible."
In the 6/97 EWR I wrote, "it is highly likely that within three years or so US officials will have completely lost military control of the Persian Gulf as well as every other piece of real estate they think they own." I have seen nothing to change this forecast.
Fascinating, and perhaps wildly profitable. Time will tell.
Richard Maybury, March-April 1999 EWR
Update - Saudi Oil War — August 2000 EWR
Five years ago, in the 2/95 EWR, I wrote a lengthy analysis called "The Coming Saudi Oil War." I pointed out that when Saudi Arabia sneezes, US investment markets catch pneumonia.
Explaining some of the history few westerners understand, I said Saudi Arabia is a misleading name, the real name is Arabia. The Saudis are a tribe that conquered the other Arabian tribes, with British help. Today these conquerors dominate the other tribes and live in amazing opulence from all the oil money. Washington has replaced the British as their protectors. This is one of the main reasons Washington is not loved in the Mideast.
In that 2/95 article I pointed out that the Saudi dictators have averted rebellion by spreading the oil money around, creating one of the world's most extensive welfare states.
By 1995, the "real" (inflation adjusted) oil price was below the level of 1975, and the Saudis' ability to buy the tolerance of their subjects was evaporating.
On top of this was the fact that Iraq and Iran owned the Persian Gulf for thousands of years and they want it back.
The Saudi dictators are the "swing producers" of the oil markets. They control the world price by adjusting their oil output.
The only thing standing between the Saudis and the Iraqis and Iranians is the US Navy. Washington protects the Saudi thugs in exchange for their agreement to keep the oil price down.
The oil price is a barometer of the fickle Saudi dictators' relations with Washington. A low price means they are obeying Washington. A high price, Iraq and Iran.
In a 3/99 update, I said I thought conditions had changed. The oil war was over, the US had lost; the Saudis had secretly capitulated and formed a clandestine alliance with Iran.
Oil lately has been in the $30 range and gasoline prices are again in the headlines.
The significant news now is that $30 oil has not been enough to rescue the Saudis. The Arabian economy is creating only one new job for every three Arabs entering the work force. Poverty spreads. The south side of Riyadh has become a third-world slum, with Arabs living in tin shacks.
The Saudi dictators are under siege, receiving extreme pressure from Iraq, Iran and their own population to generate more oil revenue.
If you were the Saudis what would you do?
I could be wrong, but my guess is that any oil price declines will be only temporary, $50 oil is in the cards even if a major Persian Gulf war does not break out. If war does happen, $100.
Again, I wish I could say when. The only thing I am sure about is that Washington has lost control of the Persian Gulf. The Saudis know the anemic US armed forces can no longer protect them, so the long-term trend for oil and gasoline prices is higher, and this will lead other raw materials higher.
Incidentally, it was not so much an economic or financial analysis that enabled me to get the oil forecast right, it was a geopolitical analysis. A forecaster who is not watching the condition of the US armed forces is not watching the single most important factor in the world economy and investment markets.
------------
Saudi Arabia's population is outnumbered four to one by the Iraqis and Iranians, and we have little reason to believe the Arabian army, comprised of the conquered tribes, is loyal to the ruling family. In my view, oil below $25 means the Saudis are sliding into bed with Washington; above $30, sliding into bed with Iraq and Iran. Between $25 and $30 they are trying to keep both sides happy and probably making both sides angry. Due to the weakened state of the US armed forces, I am betting Iraq and Iran will win.
Richard Maybury, August 2000 EWR
END
U.S. & World Early Warning Report® . Published ten times per year. © 1991-2007 Henry Madison Research, Inc., PO Box 84908, Phoenix, AZ 85071.
Phone toll-free 1-800-509-5400. Outside US: 602-252-4477. Fax: 602-943-2363.
Visa, MasterCard accepted. www.chaostan.com
|